Holiday Dilemma: To Re-Gift or Not To Re-Gift?

Christmas Enviro GirlWe’ve all received that gift, you know the one, the wildly inappropriate item we either cannot use or absolutely dislike.  Is it wrong to pass on a gift given to us as a gift for somebody else?  Enviro Girl argues that in most situations, re-gifting is perfectly acceptable, provided you are sensible and sensitive.  It’s silly to hold on to things you can’t use and don’t like, it’s much better to pass along a gift to someone who will enjoy it put it to good use.  What are the rules regarding re-gifting?

Was it handmade?  Let’s say your grandmother spent nine months sewing you a quilt that does not go with your home decorating style.  Obviously something handmade involves sentimental value, so you cannot re-gift a quilt carrying nine months of your grandmother’s life and love sewn into it.  In general, something handmade should not be re-gifted if it was made specifically for the recipient.  The only caveat Enviro Girl can think of for this rule is if the handmade was mass-produced, like her strawberry jam.  Let’s say she makes gallons of homegrown and homemade jam, jam not expressly made for any individual.  In the case of her jam, re-gifting the jar she gave them (unopened, of course), would be fine.  In the case of the unwanted quilt, Enviro Girl suggests shelving it for another relative (child, niece, nephew) and passing it along at an appropriate time.  The key to handling a handmade gift is sensitivity.

Does the gift have sentimental value?  Family heirlooms fall into this category, although it’s fair to argue that what’s sentimental to one person can have zero value to another.  Years ago one of Enviro Girl’s great-uncles gave one of her sons a toy car emblazoned with the logo of a local business.  It’s an antique, her sons have zero interest in cars or antiques, the great-uncle has since passed and Enviro Girl knows someone who’d get a kick out of the car because it’s old and has this particular name on it.  Enviro Girl believes in her heart her great-uncle would prefer the car go to someone who would truly appreciate its value.  If the intent of re-gifting is to match the value of a gift with a recipient who will value it, Enviro Girl says Go For It!

Is it timely?  Re-gifting last year’s hot toy as a birthday gift because your child got two last Christmas is both cheap and wrong.  Never, ever re-gift something that is not trendy or has expired.  That’s plain old common sense.

Would someone’s feelings be hurt if they knew you were passing along their gift to you?  This is your best litmus test and it involves sensitivity.  Every year Enviro Girl’s grandma sends her home with three pounds of chocolates.  Every year Enviro Girl brings boxes of those chocolates along to holiday parties as hostess gifts to share–grandma won’t mind those chocolates being enjoyed by a crowd instead of getting stale and eventually tossed into the garbage back at Enviro Girl’s house.  She’s honest about where the chocolates came from (“My grandmother gave us these lovely chocolates for Christmas and they’re too good not to share!”).  She uses common sense and doesn’t pass along the gift in the same circles that her grandma travels.  This bring us to the next point:

Will the gift-giver or recipient find out you re-gifted?  This involves sensitivity and common sense.  Enviro Girl thinks you’re pretty safe to re-gift if you think about your social circles.  A co-worker gives you a coffee mug you’ve absolutely no use for?  Go ahead and give it to somebody in your book club, freshly wrapped with a new gift tag, of course.

Will the recipient like the gift more than you did?  If the answer to this question is “Yes!” then absolutely re-gift.  Enviro Girl believes if people considered this question, they would actually prevent a lot of re-gifting in the first place.   Each time Enviro Girl receives body lotions and soaps from others, she sets them aside to give to her mother-in-law.  Enviro Girl has freakishly sensitive skin, most people giving her those benign tubes of lotions and body washes don’t know better.  Enviro Girl knows her mother-in-law loves strong-scented lotions and body washes and will use every last drop.  Enviro Girl has never felt a twinge of guilt passing on something she knows another person will truly value.

Is the gift in good condition?  If it’s not, don’t embarrass yourself.  Donate the item to charity.  But if it’s unused, unread, or unopened, it should be safe to give again to someone else.  Now, if the item has been used but you want to re-gift it anyway, you need to be upfront and tell the person (i.e. “I read this book and I know you’ll enjoy it, too!”).

There are politics to re-gifting, but with diplomacy, common sense and sensitivity you can pass along things and make others happier in the process.  Enviro Girl believes there is NO shame in re-gifting.

Tell the Eco Women:  Do you re-gift?


2 thoughts on “Holiday Dilemma: To Re-Gift or Not To Re-Gift?

  1. I LOVE this post. I totally believe in regifting but being that I just made a quilt for my daughter…I would be hurt if she gave it away. Maybe not if she gave it away in a couple years but right now yeah, I’d be hurt. GREAT tips.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s